I ditched most streaming services well over a year ago now, but Spotify has clung on because I have a playlist of around 2000 songs. I’ve set up Navidrome but now need to transfer all my music in the highest quality possible as efficiently as possible.

I tried lidarr some time ago, but it seemed to be based more around artists than individual songs and my indexer failed to find most of my library.

I’ve seen a couple of apps that will look at a playlist and then try to yt-dlp the song from YouTube but I’m worried about having a lower quality or different version. I’ve wondered if automating an “analog hole” type approach where I just pipe the audio of each song to a file and leave it playing overnight for a couple of weeks might actually be the best approach but that does seem a bit insane at this scale.

  • themakara@lemmy.worldEnglish
    11·
    14 小时前

    Here’s the not really legal way I have heard of

    1. Get a Deezer trail and cancle the sub right after. Migrate your relevant playlists to Deezer.
    2. Use Deemix to download the playlist any anything you are interested in in the quality you desire. Make sure the DL settings are also what you want. You can also use other tools to download from Qobuz.
    3. (Optional) Use Musicbrainz to identify and tag your files with unique IDs. You can also use custom scripts to give the artist field seperate entries for every artist. Makes it more convenient then separation by a ; or something. You can use ChatGPT for the script.
    4. (Still optional) Import the music to a Lidarr instance for better management and automatic naming. The IDs make this step easier. This allows you too track new or missing releases from artists.
    5. Import to Navidrome.

    The optional steps can be more involved and need a lot of manual work. Also, the migration to Deezer will have issues, it’s not perfect.

    If you want lyrics, I recommend using LRCGET or importing to Jellyfin and using it’s lyric plugin to automatically download them that way. The app SongSync on android also allows downloading lyrics automatically and manually from a variety is sources, including Apple and Spotify. Not on FDroid or Play, use GitHub or IzzyOnDroid.

    As for a music player on android, I’m currents trying Symfonium. Not FOSS and actually paid, but so far it’s the best I have seen.

    EDIT: Minor clarification.

    • Appoxo@lemmy.dbzer0.comEnglish
      3·
      11 小时前

      Theres tools like Zotify (and I am sure several others) to directly download the music files from Spotify.
      No need to get yet another subscription.
      They may not be lossless but who really cares when the first priority is getting away from it at all.

      • themakara@lemmy.worldEnglish
        73·
        11 小时前

        In my experience, most of these tools usually only search the equivalent song on YouTube ans download it from there. Which can cause some trouble when the algorithm finds some cover etc instead of the original thing. Plus the lossless issue. For me personally, it was easier to just get the better version outright instead of upgrading afterwards.

          • themakara@lemmy.worldEnglish
            2·
            8 小时前

            I commented that I have experience with similar tools and that is why I chose others. I never said anything about this particular one.

            Why would I need to look into this particular tool right now? I don’t need it and it has no real relevance to what I was saying either.